| 1827 – 1828 | John Copeland |
| 1829 | Joseph Atwell |
| 1830 – 1831 | Chester V. Aldgate |
| 1832 | Richard Wright |
| 1833 | Manly Tooker & Wm. H. Goodwin |
| 1834 | S.D.W. Chase/ Edward Bannister |
| 1835 – 1836 | Philo E. Brown |
| 1837 – 1838 | Gideon D. Perry |
| 1839 | Chauncey S. Baker |
| 1840 | Edward Bannister |
| 1840 | Henry Ryan Smith |
| 1842 – 1843 | Seymour A. Baker |
| 1844 – 1845 | Joseph T. Arnold |
| 1846 | Henry Hitchcock |
| 1847 | Arnos Hard |
| 1848 | Isaac Kingsley |
| 1849 – 1850 | Henry Ryan Smith |
| 1851 – 1852 | D. Cheeseman |
| 1853 | Samuel C. Church |
| 1854 – 1855 | Benjamin Titus Roberts |
| 1856 | William C. Kendall |
| 1857 | Chauncey S. Baker |
| 1858 – 1859 | Elias M. Buck |
| 1860 | William S. Tuttle |
| 1861 | Edward Alexander Rice |
| 1862 – 1863 | John Broadhead Wentworth |
| 1864 – 1865 | Peter R. Stover |
| 1866 | Edward Alexander Rice |
| 1867 – 1868 | Henry Ryan Smith |
| 1869 – 1871 | James Nelson Simkins |
| 1872 | John A. Copeland |
| 1873 – 1874 | James H. Rogeres |
| 1875 | Julius C. Hitchcock |
| 1876 – 1878 | John Dennis |
| 1879 – 1880 | M.C. Dean |
| 1881 – 1883 | Leo Herbert Dryer |
| 1884 – 1886 | Thomas Jefferson Bissell |
| 1887 – 1888 | Owen S. Chamberlayne |
| 1889 – 1892 | Almeron F. Colburn |
| 1893 – 1897 | Loren Stiles |
| 1898 – 1899 | John Edwin Williams |
| 1900 – 1901 | Robert C. Brownlee |
| 1902 – 1906 | Carlton H. Norris |
| 1907 – 1911 | Henry Edward Bayley |
| 1911 – 1915 | O.J. Blackford |
| 1915 – 1918 | J.H. Olmstead |
| 1918 – 1927 | W.F. Wells |
| 1928 – 1929 | G.W. Keeling |
| 1930 – 1932 | C.W. Taylor |
| 1933 – 1936 | R. E. Cory |
| 1937 – 1938 | R.T. Doherty |
| 1939 – 1940 | David R. Klingler |
| 1941 – 1943 | John R. Held |
| 1943 – 1955 | Frank Mucci |
| 1955 – 1957 | Karl. R. Harris |
| 1957 – 1960 | Howard R. Hall |
| 1960 – 1962 | Bruce Rahtjen |
| 1962 – 1965 | Richard Harrington |
| 1965 – 1969 | Walter B. Barger |
| 1969 – 1979 | Harvey O. Taylor |
| 1979 – 1993 | Gailey Carpenter |
| 1993 – 1999 | David Meade |
| 1999 | Richard L. Selden |
| 2000 | Steven Newton |
| 2001 – 2007 | S. Thevanesan |
| 2007 – Present | Rev. Karen "Kit" Snyder |